Update 5:33 PM Oct. 28, 2015 Finally someone agrees with me! See last story below. If the Spring Valley High School teacher and assistant principal had had more training, wisdom, finesse and good will, they wouldn't have created an out-of-control confrontation with a girl who quietly glanced at her cellphone and apologized for it. When I was a student teacher I was told, "Never start a confrontation you can't win. It undermines your authority." The teacher and assistant principal overreacted to the girl's refusal to turn over her phone. It could have been dealt with after class when it wouldn't have completely disrupted the class. But the teacher and administratorunder-reactedto the brutality by the officer toward a child in their care. Were they so angry at the girl that they wanted her to be physically assaulted? Did they want "Officer Slam" to slam the girl? Do they not recognize a crime when it's being committed before their eyes against a child they are being paid to protect? Here's an interview with Niya Kenny, a fellow student who was arrested with the girl slammed by the officer.
...Not many news agencies have reported, or even wondered why she
was asked to leave in the first place. As it turns out she had
momentarily looked at her phone during class, and apologized for it at
the time.
...[Niya] Kenny: Yes, sir he's known as Officer Slam around our school. I've heard, in the past, he's slammed pregnant women, teenage girls, he's known for Slamming.
Hayes: Um.. one of the things that's so striking in this video is the
other students in the room seem so quiet and scared and contained. No
one seems to be intervening. Why do you think that was?
Kenny: They were scared, I was scared myself. I felt the two grown
men in the class were also scared themselves because who's seen anything
like that? That's not normal for anyone to be handled like that, let
alone a 16-year-old girl by a 300 lbs man.
Hayes: You at one point did get up to say, what were you saying, what happened?
Kenny: I was screaming, crying, like "Are you guys seriously letting
this happen? This is not right, you guys know this isn't right. You guys
are really letting this happen right now?" I guess they were in shock
but still I felt like somebody in the class should have helped her.
Hayes: Did the teacher or the administrator say anything to the
officer like "hey, this is excessive" or try to intercede in any way?
Kenny: Not at all, they were both quiet just like the kids.
Hayes: So everyone is sitting there in stunned silence, you start saying something, what happens next?
Kenny: And then the administrator, Coran Webb who was also in the
class, starts telling me "Sit down Niya, be quiet Niya, put your phone
away Niya." And I'm like "No, no, this is not right. I can't believe
ya'll are doing this to her."
Hayes: And then you then, are eventually arrested?
Kenny: Yes, sir.
Original post:
Why isn't anyone questioning the actions of the teacher and assistant principal at Spring Valley High School?
by Maura Larkins
It seems that the South Carolina SRO (school resource officer) did pretty much what the teacher and assistant principal expected him to do when he dragged a girl out of her high school classroom.
The assistant principal made the decision to call the officer into the classroom. It appears that he wanted the officer to use force. Or perhaps he just thought the officer would be able to intimidate the girl and she would get up and leave voluntarily. He clearly did not tell the officer NOT to use force. I can certainly understand if the officer believed that he was expected to use force.
The LA Times notes, "[Sheriff] Lott, who rushed home from an out-of-town conference when the news
broke, said that ateacher and vice principal in the classroom at the
time felt the officer acted appropriately."
What was the girl's offense? Texting in class.
Compare this case to a situation in Sacramento that did indeed require the school to use force: a principal was body-slammed!
COLUMBIA, S.C. — Videos of a white sheriff’s deputy throwing a black high school girl
to the floor of a classroom thrust this community into an unsettling
national discussion Tuesday about whether black students are
disproportionately punished.
The incident, which the Justice Department said Tuesday that it would investigate, follows national studies showing that black students were far more likely than whites to be disciplined in public schools, even for comparable offenses.
That
issue was receiving intense scrutiny here long before the videos of
Monday’s incident were released, prompting the district to form a task
force last year to examine its practices.
Last year, the racial divide in the Richland School District Two,
encompassing parts of this city and its suburbs, led to the formation of
the Black Parents Association, and contributed to a bitter campaign for
control of the district’s board.
Yet
this community fits no neat stereotype of racial tension. It has at
times been seen as a model of amicable integration, where students of
divergent backgrounds socialize together. And while some students have
called the deputy overly rough or racist, others, of all races, defend
his record in the school — if not his behavior on the videos.
The videos showed a sheriff’s deputy
assigned to Spring Valley High School struggling with a 16-year-old
girl who had refused to stand and leave her math class, after the
teacher reportedly caught her using her phone. The deputy, Ben Fields,
tipped the girl’s chair and desk backward, lifting her out of her seat
and slamming her to the floor, and then dragged her to the front of the
classroom, where he cuffed her hands behind her back.
Sheriff
Leon Lott of Richland County said at a news conference Tuesday that in
one video, when the deputy grabbed the girl, she could be seen punching
him, but he said his focus was on whether the deputy followed
departmental rules. “That’s what the internal affairs investigation is
doing, and the results of that will determine his further employment
here,” he said.
“Even
though she was wrong for disturbing the class, even though she refused
to abide by the directions of the teacher, the school administrator and
also the verbal commands of our deputy, I’m looking at what our deputy
did,” Sheriff Lott said.
He deflected a question about the role of race, saying Deputy Fields has a black girlfriend.
[Maura Larkins' note: I wonder if the black girlfriend also gets dragged around.]
On
Monday, the sheriff placed Deputy Fields on unpaid leave, and asked for
a federal investigation. The Justice Department’s Civil Rights
Division, along with the F.B.I. and the United States attorney for South
Carolina, said Tuesday that it would look into the incident.
James Manning, the chairman of the district’s board, said the use of force “appears to me to be excessive and unnecessary.”
Deputy
Fields has been the subject of two federal lawsuits about his conduct
in the past. A jury found in his favor in one, and the other is
pending...
Twice
this week, the nation was moved by the way a white cop confronted a
black teenaged girl and her mobile phone. For very different reasons.
In South Carolina, the teen was texting in math class and wouldn’t put her phone away. Teens and their phones, right?
But
the campus officer who came to the class responded in the worst
possible way, yanking, slamming and dragging the girl across the
classroom. It was a violent 11 seconds of video that made millions of
people gasp and, thankfully, got the cop fired.
Sadly,
in this time of a national awakening to stunning incidents of Bad Cop
brutality — from ruthless arrests caught on camera to fatal shootings —
this has become what we expect to see.
But many of this country’s 780,000 sworn police officers know how to do their jobs the right way.
In
Washington, police showed up in a neighborhood near the Nationals
baseball stadium to break up a fight between two groups of teens. After
it was over, 17-year-old Aaliyah Taylor,
a senior at Ballou High School, walked up to the officer and started
playing “Watch Me (Whip/Nae Nae)” on her phone. Instead of clearing out,
as the police officer had demanded that she and the rest of the crowd
do, she started dancing the Nae Nae. You could totally see a teen doing
this, right?
That officer had a choice. Yell at the teen
for being defiant and disrespectful? Go rogue and slam the teen to the
ground, South Carolina-style?
Nope. Instead, the officer
began dancing, too, matching Aaliyah move for move. It was a hilarious,
uplifting and refreshing 56 seconds of video that immediately went
viral.
It
shouldn’t be news that a police officer used her humanity to defuse a
tense situation instead of escalating it, that a white cop didn’t use
force against a black teen. But for many people in Aaliyah’s community,
it was.
All seven of her siblings have been cuffed or arrested
by police for nonviolent crimes, like breaking curfew, she told The
Washington Post’s Perry Stein. And her brother and six sisters all told
her that the police were rough on them. We saw that video in South
Carolina. We know it happens.
Aaliyah lives in a rapidly changing city that is becoming less and less welcoming to people who look like her.
Her
neighborhood near Ballou High School in Southeast Washington is a world
of jump-outs and street corner pat-downs. Dozens of students at her
school have been killed in the past decade. You’re wearing a hoodie?
Dark pants? You’re going to get stopped. Kids in her neighborhood run
when they see police.
Surveys and studies — Gallup, Pew, USA
Today — show that nationwide, African Americans aren’t confident in the
way police interact with their communities.
“I thought all cops were cruel because that’s how I saw them,” Aaliyah explained later.
The
police officer, rather than taking her down like a drug kingpin caught
in a sting, laughed at Aaliyah’s challenge to her authority, warned her
that she had better moves and started dancing, clunky cop shoes,
turtle-shell body armor and all.
“Instead of us fighting, she
tried to turn it around and make it something fun,” Aaliyah said. “I
never expected cops to be that cool. There are some good cops.”...
Victim of SC school assault “had it coming”
By Brandi Collins
ColorofChange. org
Oct. 28 2015
By now you’ve probably heard about the
horrifying and brutal attack of a peaceful Black female high school
student by school Police Officer Ben Fields - an officer with a history
of racial profiling.1 Just hours after the incident,
some media had already begun its routine character assassination of the
Black student and its blind hero worshiping of the officer. The most
vile of this coverage came from CNN’s Harry Houck.
Just like when he was covering the murder of Sandra Bland, Harry Houck thinks this young Black girl “had it coming.”2 That if she only respected the officer she would not have been viciously attacked.
As an ex-NYPD detective with a national
platform, Harry Houck continues to pedal racist narratives that put
Black lives at risk by suggesting that officers have the right to use
abusive force on Black women who don’t respect them. It's an
embarrassment for the network and it should embarrass corporate sponsors
that their money is reinforcing for millions of viewers the both
conscious and unconscious belief that Black is wrong, the police are
always right, and any lack of respect for an officer by a woman of color
justifies a beating or worse..
The South Carolina high school student flipped and thrown across a
classroom by the disgraced sheriff's deputy who lost his job Wednesday
is living in foster care, her lawyer told the Daily News.
The 16-year-old is now under the protection of a foster mom who said she's suffering in the aftermath of the shocking caught-on-video assault, lawyer Todd Rutherford said Wednesday.
News of the unidentified teen's status surfaced as Richland County Sheriff's Deputy Ben Fields was stripped of his badge for his violent reaction to her allegedly unruly behavior.
The Monday incident inside an algebra class at Spring Valley High
School was captured in disturbing cellphone footage that quickly went
viral and raised renewed concerns about racist policing and excessive
force. Fields is white, and the student is black.
"Deputy Ben Fields did wrong this past Monday, so we're taking
responsibility for that," Sheriff Leon Lott of Richland County said at a
news conference in Columbia announcing the dismissal.
"The maneuver that he used was not based on the training or
acceptable," Lott said, adding that the termination "wasn't a hard
decision."
Lott praised the classmates who filmed the officer's overreaction and
even encouraged citizens to keep filming cops to help "police the
police."
The Justice Department also is investigating the case, and Fields may face criminal charges from that probe.
Fields earned nationwide scorn for the video showing him slamming the
girl to the ground while she was still caught in her desk, and then
dragging her across the classroom floor after she allegedly refused to
stop using her cellphone.
Fields' lawyer issued a defiant statement late Wednesday, thanking people for their "heartfelt support."
"We believe that Mr. Fields' actions were justified and lawful
throughout the circumstances of which he was confronted during this
incident," lawyer Scott Hayes said.
"To that extent, we believe that Mr. Fields' actions were carried out
professionally and that he was performing his job duties within the
legal threshold," he said.
Hayes said his client "welcomes the opportunity to address the particulars at the appropriate time."
While confirming Fields' dismissal, Sheriff Lott criticized the teen
for allegedly starting the confrontation and said that she still could
face prosecution.
Richland County Sheriff's Department--Ben Fields has a history of alleged misconduct and is being sued by an expelled Spring Valley student for racial bias.
The girl and a fellow female student who objected to Fields' actions
were charged with disturbing the school. Both were released to their
guardians.
"She was not allowing the teacher to teach, she was not allowing the
students to learn," he said. "She was very disruptive, very
disrespectful."
Her teacher tried to discipline her and called a school administrator for help before bringing in Fields, he said.
Fields was allowed to put his hands on the girl and tell her she was under arrest, Lott said, but he went too far.
"I can tell you what he should not have done: He should not have thrown that student," Lott said.
Rutherford said the girl suffered injuries to her arm, neck and face.
Lott claimed the girl suffered only "rug burn."...
Black girls are suspended at six times the rate of white girls
Maura Larkins' comment: I estimate that thousands of white girls send texts during high school math classes everyday, but we would be truly shocked if one of them were dragged out of class by a police officer and arrested.
Press release by Color of Change Oct. 28, 2015:
...While Fields' firing was absolutely necessary, he [should not be] alone in shouldering the blame for this incident.
From start to finish, there was a total breakdown in common sense and
compassion for the student who he brutalized. Even Sheriff Lott has
questioned whether the officer should have ever been called into the
classroom.2
The educators who involved a police officer in
this minor disciplinary issue and the policy makers who have failed to
limit the role of police in schools must also be held accountable.
Join
us in urging Richland School District 2 authorities to investigate the
school officials who called Officer Fields and to strictly limit the
role of police in their schools. During today's press conference, it was revealed that school
officials issued statements in support of Officer Fields after videos of
his violent attack went viral.3 It's shameful. Any
school official who found Officer Fields' behavior acceptable shouldn't
be educating our children. This type of discriminatory police violence
has no place in Richland County schools and local leadership must do
everything in their power to stop it. As long as policies allow
educators to bring in police for any minor school issue we can expect to
see more and more tragic cases like this one. Richland School District 2
Superintendent Debbie Ham has said she will work to strengthen police
"training efforts in the school," but we need more than that.4 ColorOfChange members know all too well that the police
violence caught on camera at Spring Valley High is part of a much larger
crisis of criminalization targeting Black students. In the
past few years, the number of police in schools has skyrocketed and the
result has been devastating. Known as the "school to prison pipeline,"
kids are now much more likely to be suspended, expelled and arrested for
the type of issues that years ago would have landed a student in the
principal's office.5 Black girls — who face dehumanizing
racial and gender stereotypes — are 6 times more likely than white girls
to be suspended, most commonly for subjective issues such as "having a
bad attitude."6 Police should play no role in the everyday education and disciplining of students.
— Arisha, Rashad, Scott, Lyla and the rest of the ColorOfChange team.
On the same night members of the San Diego Unified school
board will discuss an independent investigation into possible wrongdoing
by board president Marne Foster, board members will double down on
their support for Foster by honoring her with a proclamation...
...Despite
the shady shenanigans at SCPA, has Marne Foster been a good board
member for her area? If so, maybe she deserves a slight break here?
Maura Larkins' comment to Dennis--and to Richard Barrera, who "will ask the board to consider which issues are truly relevant to the school district":
School officials who get rid of good employees for political reasons are seriously undermining the welfare of students. Schools need officials who keep their personal agendas out of their decision-making process.
In my opinion, SDUSD
is no worse than other school districts.
I'm asking myself why is it
that "shady shenanigans" seem to be rarely investigated when the
perpetrators are white.
Officials have been allowed
to resign suddenly in other county school districts with no reasonable
explanation being given, yet officials of color seem to get investigated. My
theory is that the discrepancy is NOT CAUSED BY RACISM, but rather by
the fact that people of color don't have the political clout that allows
them to accomplish their goals behind closed doors.
I have long argued that there is too much secrecy in schools. A new lawsuit (see NBC 7 article below) makes the same case.
The Michael Gurrieri lawsuit (see NBC 7 article below) against Cindy Marten, the superintendent of San Diego Unified School District, claims that Marten knew and approved of the firing of Gurrieri, an internal investigator who looked into a serious sexual molestation problem at an elementary school. The district wanted Gurrieri's report to be cleansed to cover-up the fact that the principal failed to act to protect children. Gurrieri refused to censor his report as the district demanded, and he was fired.
Marten has filed a Motion to Dismiss herself as a defendant in the case, claiming that Gurrieri has no proof that Marten was involved.
I think Marten is a pretty good superintendent; it is the system itself that is bad. In my experience, almost all school districts simply do whatever they want to do, and then have their lawyers protect officials from responsibility.
The question of Marten's involvement in personnel actions has been raised regarding the removal of another principal. Many believe that a principal was removed from her school in retaliation for failing to make sure that board member Marne Foster's son got a good college recommendation.
The District Deeds blog and Voice of San Diego have written about recently discovered emails showing that Marten was informed of Marne Foster's wishes.
"Regardless of the reason why she removed Lizarraga, the latest emails show that Marten was aware of Foster’s overreach at the school.”
-- Reporter Mario Koran – Voice of San Diego
Koran has proven, through multiple emails and communication between Trustee Marne Foster and former Chief Student Services Officer Joe Fulcher that copied Supt. Cindy Marten, that BOTH FOSTER AND MARTEN VIOLATED SDUSD Board of Education Policy which states:
"The board will not give direction to any employee other than the superintendent and any other employee who may report directly to the board.”
There is INDISPUTABLE PROOF in the emails that Trustee Foster GAVE DIRECTION to Joe Fulcher …AND THAT CINDY MARTEN IMPROPERLY MADE IT HAPPEN!!!
After
the San Diego Unified School District paid $105,000 to settle a lawsuit alleging
sexual assault in a boy's bathroom, a new suit has been filed relating to
the case.
A former employee who alleged a
"cover up" of student-on-student sexual misconduct at SD Unified will
soon be heading to settlement talks with the district.
A September 24 date has been set for
settlement negotiations in the suit brought by former school district
investigator Michael Gurrieri. He was
hired by SDUSD in March 2014 as a probationary internal investigator.
Gurrieri claims he uncovered a
problem of student-on-student sexual assaults within the district as he was
looking into an allegation at Green Elementary School in San Carlos.
In May 2013, parents of a
kindergartener said their son was sexually assaulted by another kindergarten
student in the boy's bathroom at Green Elementary. The parents were awarded $105,000 to settle a lawsuit in the case, and the district
did not admit guilt.
When Gurrieri filed his report, he
claims he was told to remove
allegations of incidents of abuse in the school that the principal was aware of
and didn't do anything about, according to his attorney.
Gurrieri was terminated from his job because he objected to
the district's “cover- up,” his attorney claims.
The lawsuit originally named
Superintendent Cindy Marten, Executive Director of the Quality Assurance Office
Carmina Duran and the district's General Counsel Andra Donovan as defendants
because the district cannot be sued in federal court under the claims of First
Amendment violations.
A judge is considering a motion to
remove Marten and Donovan that claims Gurrieri failed to prove he had a
conversation with either Marten or Donovan regarding his report.
However, Gurrieri's attorneys say
the judge has yet to make a final decision on whether Marten and Donovan will
be defendants.
Duran did instruct Gurrieri to focus his report on one
student's allegations, court documents show.
The district ended Gurrieri's
employment in October 2014, court documents show. The district has said it
will not comment on pending litigation.
Is this the future in California if UCSD wins its poaching lawsuit
against Dr. Paul Aisen regarding Aisen's decision to transfer his
Alzheimer's study to USC? Is it unlawful restraint of trade? Science
magazine reports on what happens when health systems collude to stop
their employees from moving to other institutions.
“[L]ateral moves of faculty between Duke and UNC are not permitted.”
–UNC's chief of cardiothoracic imaging
In August, we reported
on the lawsuit brought by the University of California, San Diego
(UCSD), against the University of Southern California (USC) in Los
Angeles, in an effort to stop USC’s alleged attempt to bring a
multimillion-dollar Alzheimer’s disease research project along with its
new recruit, neuroscientist Paul Aisen, from UCSD to USC. We noted that
though some observers view universities’ efforts to bring major
researchers to their campuses from elsewhere as effective recruiting,
others see it as harmful poaching.
In North Carolina, meanwhile, another scientist’s effort to move from
Duke University in Durham to the University of North Carolina (UNC),
Chapel Hill, has also resulted in a lawsuit, but for an entirely
different reason. Danielle Seaman,
an assistant professor of radiology at Duke, claims that “an illegal
conspiracy” among Duke, UNC, and the two universities’ health systems
not to raid each other’s talent barred her from consideration for an
advertised opening at UNC, according to the complaint filed with the court.
Allegedly, the institutions’ goal was to “suppress the compensation
of their employees,” according to the complaint. “Without the knowledge
or consent of their employees, [Duke’s] senior administrators and deans
entered into express agreements [with UNC] to eliminate or reduce
competition … for skilled medical labor” by not “hir[ing] or
attempt[ing] to hire” from each other. This deal, the complaint argues,
constitutes an unlawful restraint of trade.
When UNC advertised a position in cardiothoracic imaging, the
complaint claims, Seaman wrote to the division chief to express interest
in applying. As quoted in the complaint, he wrote back saying “I agree
that you would be a great fit. … Unfortunately, I just received
confirmation today from the Dean’s office that lateral moves of faculty
between Duke and UNC are not permitted. There is reasoning for this
‘guideline’ which was agreed upon between the deans of UNC and Duke a
few years back. I hope you understand.” (Emphasis is in the
original.) Seaman did not understand, so she wrote back to ask about
this “reasoning.” The guideline arose, the division chief allegedly
replied, “in response to an attempted recruitment by Duke a
couple of years ago of the entire UNC bone marrow transplant team; UNC
had to generate a large retention package to keep the team intact.” (Emphasis is in the original.)
The universities have not commented on the case, according to The Chronicle of Higher Education. Still, The Chronicle
quotes a former senior vice president for public affairs and government
relations at Duke as saying, “[i]n my time in the administration, there
was a general practice that we did not recruit aggressively at the
other institution, and vice versa. … It was based on thinking both
institutions were better if each institution was strong.”
Seaman is represented by a North Carolina law firm and also by Lieff,
Cabraser, Heimann & Bernstein (no relation to this reporter), the
San Francisco-based legal powerhouse that won a $415 million settlement
against tech giants Google, Apple, Intel, and Adobe for colluding to
keep wages down by not hiring each other’s workers. Seaman’s complaint
requests a jury trial and approval of the case as a class action “on
behalf of a class of similarly situated individuals,” presumably the
employees of Duke and UNC. Stay tuned for developments.
Great Post Sent to Me Today
I said: it's sad they thought that kid had a bomb.
She said: they didn't think he had a bomb.
I said: yes, they thought he made a bomb and even called the police.
She said: They just wanted to humiliate a little Muslim boy. They didn't think he had a bomb.
I said: Don't be a conspiracy theorist. They might be a little prejudiced, but I'm sure they thought he had a bomb.
She said: OK. But they didn't evacuate the school, like you do when there's a bomb.
They didn't call a bomb squad - like you do when there's a bomb.
They didn't get as far away from him as possible, like you do when there's a bomb.
Then they put him and the clock in an office: not like you do when there's a bomb
Then they waited with him for the police to arrive, and then they put the clock in the same car as the police.
Then they took pictures of it.
I said: Damn.....They never thought he had a bomb.
Boy arrested at school for building a digital lock
"How did a bunch of complete idiots end up
accidentally running a school? Were you all yanked out of a zoo and
given paychecks? Learning centers are for teaching...not for ruining
innocent people's lives with your racism and pathetic stupidity!..."This
kid is destined to be something great if the dimwits of Irving don't
ruin him first."
--Kevin McKinney
Is there something wrong with teacher culture?
by Maura Larkins
My explanation for the disgraceful incident in Irving, Texas where a boy was arrested for building a clock is that adults in schools so rarely engage in critical thinking. A teacher who engages in critical thinking will most likely be unpopular. There isn't a place for such teachers in the powerful cliques that run schools. I have long wondered why teachers are expected to teach critical thinking to kids when so many of them seem to be incapable of it.
Also, a culture of hostility and contempt toward students is cultivated by many teachers who are zealous in their efforts to catch students being bad--and then to run to the teachers lounge to denounce the children they are paid to nurture.
This culture creates a tendency toward paranoia among teachers and administrators.
Update Sep. 17, 2015:
...Ahmed spoke about his arrest today on ABC News' "Good Morning America," describing how his English teacher and police reacted to his clock, which is still in police custody.
"She saw a clock that, in her opinion, looked like a threat to her,"
Ahmed said of the unnamed teacher. "It felt really weird getting
arrested because I never thought I'd ever get arrested....
When
Ahmed Mohamed went to his high school in Irving, Texas, Monday, he was
so excited. A teenager with dreams of becoming an engineer, he wanted to
show his teacher the digital clock he'd made from a pencil case.
The
14-year-old's day ended not with praise, but punishment, after the
school called police and he was arrested. A photo shows Ahmed, wearing a
NASA t-shirt, looking confused and upset as he's being led out of
school in handcuffs.
"They arrested me and they told me that I committed the crime of a hoax bomb, a fake bomb," the freshman later explained to WFAA after authorities released him..
Is this the future in California if UCSD wins its poaching lawsuit against Dr. Paul Aisen regarding Aisen's decision to transfer his Alzheimer's study to USC? Is it unlawful restraint of trade? Science magazine reports on what happens when health systems collude to stop their employees from moving to other institutions.
“[L]ateral moves of faculty between Duke and UNC are not permitted.”
–UNC's chief of cardiothoracic imaging
In August, we reported
on the lawsuit brought by the University of California, San Diego
(UCSD), against the University of Southern California (USC) in Los
Angeles, in an effort to stop USC’s alleged attempt to bring a
multimillion-dollar Alzheimer’s disease research project along with its
new recruit, neuroscientist Paul Aisen, from UCSD to USC. We noted that
though some observers view universities’ efforts to bring major
researchers to their campuses from elsewhere as effective recruiting,
others see it as harmful poaching.
In North Carolina, meanwhile, another scientist’s effort to move from
Duke University in Durham to the University of North Carolina (UNC),
Chapel Hill, has also resulted in a lawsuit, but for an entirely
different reason. Danielle Seaman,
an assistant professor of radiology at Duke, claims that “an illegal
conspiracy” among Duke, UNC, and the two universities’ health systems
not to raid each other’s talent barred her from consideration for an
advertised opening at UNC, according to the complaint filed with the court.
Allegedly, the institutions’ goal was to “suppress the compensation
of their employees,” according to the complaint. “Without the knowledge
or consent of their employees, [Duke’s] senior administrators and deans
entered into express agreements [with UNC] to eliminate or reduce
competition … for skilled medical labor” by not “hir[ing] or
attempt[ing] to hire” from each other. This deal, the complaint argues,
constitutes an unlawful restraint of trade.
When UNC advertised a position in cardiothoracic imaging, the
complaint claims, Seaman wrote to the division chief to express interest
in applying. As quoted in the complaint, he wrote back saying “I agree
that you would be a great fit. … Unfortunately, I just received
confirmation today from the Dean’s office that lateral moves of faculty
between Duke and UNC are not permitted. There is reasoning for this
‘guideline’ which was agreed upon between the deans of UNC and Duke a
few years back. I hope you understand.” (Emphasis is in the
original.) Seaman did not understand, so she wrote back to ask about
this “reasoning.” The guideline arose, the division chief allegedly
replied, “in response to an attempted recruitment by Duke a
couple of years ago of the entire UNC bone marrow transplant team; UNC
had to generate a large retention package to keep the team intact.” (Emphasis is in the original.)
The universities have not commented on the case, according to The Chronicle of Higher Education. Still, The Chronicle
quotes a former senior vice president for public affairs and government
relations at Duke as saying, “[i]n my time in the administration, there
was a general practice that we did not recruit aggressively at the
other institution, and vice versa. … It was based on thinking both
institutions were better if each institution was strong.”
Seaman is represented by a North Carolina law firm and also by Lieff,
Cabraser, Heimann & Bernstein (no relation to this reporter), the
San Francisco-based legal powerhouse that won a $415 million settlement
against tech giants Google, Apple, Intel, and Adobe for colluding to
keep wages down by not hiring each other’s workers. Seaman’s complaint
requests a jury trial and approval of the case as a class action “on
behalf of a class of similarly situated individuals,” presumably the
employees of Duke and UNC. Stay tuned for developments.
That's what Assemblywoman Shirley Weber asked in April in an impassioned speech in Sacramento as she faced the fact that her bill to create meaningful teacher evaluations was pushed aside.
We're at an important moment in local education. Some schools are
failing their neighborhoods. How do we recruit, retain, evaluate and
support great teachers for all students?
"If we are not about the business of improving the lives of
children, in multiple ways, then what the hell are we doing?" Weber
asked.
We can't assume that some are lost because of their circumstances.
"If children are defined by their current circumstances of poverty, and
we don't think we can change the trajectory of their lives by great
teaching, then what are we doing? It impacted my life. I'm a kid raised
in the projects of Los Angeles, the Pueblos, some of the poorest
communities of Los Angeles. But I had great teachers. I value teachers.
... I know what the power of good teaching does," Weber said.
If you care about schools and teachers, you will want to hear Shirley Weber talk to me about them.
Listen to her story and the conversation it provokes. You can email questions to me now at scott.lewis@voiceofsandiego.org or by replying to this email.
You're not going to want to miss this conversation. Tickets are free. RSVP now.
One Voice at a Time with Shirley Weber
Tuesday, September 15 7:00 - 9:00 PM
Creative, Performing and Media Arts School
5050 Conrad Avenue | San Diego, CA 92117
Turns out a tough analysis of dysfunctional management at Poway Unified School District that we got after a public records battle was a lot tougher before we got it.
Superintendent John Collins decided to take a red pen to a $40,000 consultant’s report about district tech problems.
VOSD’s
Ashly McGlone uncovered the superintendent’s significant edits, but
only after we threatened the district with litigation. As she reports,
“words like ‘arrogance’ were replaced with ‘overconfidence.’
‘Dysfunction’ became ‘issues.’ ‘Extreme and even chaotic’
decision-making became just ‘problematic’ and ‘reckless and wasteful
decision-making’ became ‘uncontrolled and inefficient,’ while other
descriptors like ‘short-sighted’ and longer passages were scrubbed
entirely, district records show.”
The
superintendent’s told us this about the report: “The result has helped
us to celebrate the outstanding work we do and formulate new goals and
organizational structures to continuously improve upon our successes.”
A
tech staffer went to a meeting with Collins and said the chief wanted
to avoid “calling anybody out for the problems that were discovered.”
Parents at West Valley Elementary in Silicon Valley are rightly upset by the disruption caused by the involuntary transfer of all twenty-five teachers from their children's school--and I agree that this is a bad situation for the students. But the causes of the current dismal situation might be more complex than parents think. I doubt that the most recent principal was the sole cause of the conflict. I
suspect that an unhealthy culture developed at the school over a number of years. Most schools are highly political institutions with constant maneuvering by certain teachers and administrators to establish power. There are usually a few people struggling to behave professionally, but those people are not likely to be highly influential for the simple reason that humans tend to follow those who have the most political power. Parents need to establish a new culture of healthy, open communication among all adults at the school--and the PTA might not be the ideal vehicle for this. A new organization of parents concerned about poor communication at the school would seem to be a reasonable response to the crisis. While parents do not have the right to be informed about personnel matters, they DO have the right to establish a culture of open discussion and mutual respect among all stakeholders. It's amazing how much trouble can result from small problems that are not handled professionally by teachers and administrators. Teacher cliques sometimes react with remarkable outrage to small changes in daily schedules, curriculum, training programs and committee assignments. And the most powerful teachers often launch into destructive fury when they are given unpopular class assignments or when the principal fails to suspend a student when the teacher demands it. But administrators are often even more politically motivated than teachers. "WVE town" provided this reaction to my original post about this story:
...The teachers
were asked to attend a consultant's "Human Systems Dynamics" training
class, which the Superintendent falsely portrayed as "multiple
interventions". Superintendent Gudalewicz discussed it with the School
Board in a single closed session without a vote, and then she told
parents that teachers would apply and interview for to return to their
positions, but internal district leaks revealed that all the teachers
would be transferred. Within a week, they started using the description
"reconstitution", Superintendent Gudalewicz, and the School Board led
by Phyllis Vogel, refused to meet with parents in open meetings all
through the summer. One thing to note is that the consultant Royce
Holladay of Human Systems Dynamics that was paid $15,000 to "facilitate"
the failed teacher session is now hired to facilitate the "re-imaging"
of the school which was said would take 3 to 5 years. From the internal
emails obtained, it is a story of administration arrogance and
retribution, facilitated with some consultant greed.
"WVE town" also wrote this very interesting piece
for the Cupertino Patch, summarizing the secretive and dishonest
behavior of district officials. Sadly, this secrecy and dishonesty
sounds typical of most school districts. If anyone is going to start an
honest, open discussion it will have to be parents.
Why am I not surprised that Jay Martinez was an award-winning educator? It's long past time for an effective evaluation system for teachers--partly because we need to know who we're dealing with when teachers move into jobs as administrators.
ALBUQUERQUE,
N.M. — New Mexico's attorney general said Monday he will investigate
how the state's largest school district hired a high-level administrator
who faces child sex abuse charges in Colorado.
The district's new superintendent, meanwhile, faces increasing pressure to resign over the debacle.
Attorney
General Hector Balderas announced his office will look into why
Albuquerque Public Schools' safety protocols were dismissed and former
deputy superintendent Jason Martinez was hired in June before a
background check was completed.
Superintendent Luis Valentino hired Martinez to head the district's instruction and technology division.
Martinez
resigned abruptly last week. It later surfaced that he faces four
felony counts of sexual assault on a child in Colorado involving two
victims. Two previous counts have been dismissed, according to the
Denver District Attorney's Office.
A
lawyer for Karen Rudys, the district's interim assistant superintendent
for human resources, said Valentino was informed multiple times about
Martinez refusing to complete his background check but ignored those
concerns.
"This
was a horrific breach of trust for the parents of APS," Balderas told
The Associated Press on Monday. He stopped short of saying if his office
would seek criminal charges, but he said the office will see if the
district conducted necessary criminal background checks on other
employees.
Valentino
was selected for the superintendent post in June, and the school board
plans to vote Thursday on whether he should be dismissed...
The
Denver Post reported Martinez won a districtwide award in 2011 for
helping design The Digital Door Project, which gathers data for teachers
and principals, including individual student data, to help improve
standardized test scores...
"The AG’s report highlighted how Mr. O’Keefe edited his videos to
appear as if he was engaging in his ACORN hi-jinks wearing
“stereotypical 1970’s pimp garb”, the intent being to suggest that ACORN
employees would willingly do business with someone dressed in this
manner. However, it turns out that O’Keefe was actually wearing a coat
and tie when he entered the ACORN offices."
That would be the same James O’Keefe who brought down community
organizing and voter registration organization ACORN in his march to
becoming a conservative icon for his alleged ‘good works’.
Matthew Phelan and Liz Farkas over at Wonkette have broken the story about the first bit of blowback resulting from O’Keefe’s brand of ‘journalism’.
It seems that the master of the cleverly edited—if highly
deceptive—video reel is now being required to pay the sum of $100,000 to
Juan Carlos Vera, a one time California
employee of ACORN. Mr. Vera had been portrayed by O’Keefe as being a
willing participant when O’Keefe and his accomplice, Hanna Giles,
proposed smuggling young women into the United States to work as prostitutes.
While Mr. Vera had no idea he was being surreptitiously video
taped—which is not surprising given that California law expressly bars
the secret recording of one’s voice or image—there was also something
Mr. O’Keefe did not know until after he released the damaging video of
his conversation with Vera for broadcast.
As soon as O’Keefe and his partner-in-crime left the ACORN location,
Mr. Vera called the police to report the entire incident. It turns out
that Vera had been playing along with O’Keefe in an effort to ensnare
O’Keefe and Giles whom Vera believed were in the act of breaking the law
by proposing to engage in the importing of young women to become
prostitutes.
Recommended by Forbes
Oops.
As part of the settlement, Mr. O’Keefe was required to say that he
“regrets any pain” he caused Mr. Vera—although I have some doubts as to
whether O’Keefe has been losing any sleep over his illegal behavior and
the harm he did to Mr. Vera.
Why might I feel that way?
Because Mr. O’Keefe’s lawyer—Los Angeles
attorney Michael Madigan—wasted no time in characterizing the $100,000
payment as a “nuisance settlement.” Apparently, when releasing videos
smearing an innocent man by suggesting he is willing to participate in
the flesh trade turns out to do that individual serious damage, it
counts as nothing more than a nuisance to Mr. O’Keefe and his attorney.
[Vera's lawyer was Eugene Iredale of San Diego.]
A report issued by the California Attorney General
in 2010 revealed that O’Keefe and Giles were given immunity from
prosecution (a serious mistake in my opinion) in exchange for turning
over the complete and unedited tapes that O’Keefe shot in Los Angeles, San Francisco and National City where O’Keefe worked his magic on Juan Carlos Vera.
The AG’s report highlighted how Mr. O’Keefe edited his videos to
appear as if he was engaging in his ACORN hi-jinks wearing
“stereotypical 1970’s pimp garb”, the intent being to suggest that ACORN
employees would willingly do business with someone dressed in this
manner. However, it turns out that O’Keefe was actually wearing a coat
and tie when he entered the ACORN offices. The report also stated that
ACORN employees “may be able to bring a private suit against O’Keefe and
Giles for recording a confidential conversation.”
Here’s hoping that Mr. Vera is but the first of many to take advantage of the opportunity to bring such a legal action.
Oddly, a Google
scan revealed no coverage of the settlement in Breitbart.com or any of
the other conservative media who so enjoyed Mr. O’Keefe’s exploits.
Go figure.
Contract Rick at thepolicypage@gmail.com and follow me on Twitter and Facebook.
HARTFORD
— School board Chairman Richard Wareing apologized to city families
this week and declared that what happened at Sport and Medical Sciences
Academy "is never going to happen again in this district."
Wareing
was referring to last month's letter from Sport and Medical Sciences, a
magnet school near Colt Park, advising the family of a low-performing
seventh-grader that transferring her elsewhere would be in the student's
"best interest."
The
letter seemed to confirm an old suspicion among education advocates:
That area magnet schools push out students who struggle academically,
essentially dumping them on impoverished neighborhood schools that are
often criticized as failing institutions.
"I'm going to be very blunt: This [expletive] stops now," Wareing said at Tuesday's board meeting. "School
choice means choice for kids, not for the people that work for our
kids," said Wareing, reading from prepared remarks. "We are a public
school system, which means we welcome and we serve every child who walks
through our door. If anyone here is not 100 percent committed to that
vision, then they need to reconcile themselves to it now, or they need
to leave."
...Wareing's
heated speech followed a recent letter from Superintendent Beth
Schiavino-Narvaez warning all school principals in the district that
student transfers will be closely monitored.
"I
am writing to you because I want to be explicit about my expectations:
all students have a right to be educated in the school in which they
enroll," Narvaez wrote in the letter sent July 20. "A student who is
failing to meet academic performance standards should not be encouraged
to transfer to another school. It is each school's responsibility to
find the path to success for each and every student."
After Matt
Conway III, executive director of the mentoring group RiseUP, posted a
redacted copy of Sport and Medical Sciences' June 25 letter online —
"Transfer paperwork has been enclosed for your convenience," the letter
stated — administrators at the school apologized to the student's family
"for any misunderstandings" and offered her intensive academic support.
But
that hasn't quelled concern from advocates and some educators who
assert that Greater Hartford magnet schools have long counseled
underperforming students to leave.
Sandra Inga, president of the
Hartford union that represents school administrators, said she heard
from several city principals who wished that Narvaez had singled out
magnet schools in her letter last week...
"Because
it's not all the neighborhood schools — Bulkeley's not doing that,
Weaver's not doing that, Hartford High is not doing that," Inga said
after the board meeting. "It's the magnet schools ... . They've been
doing that for years."...
UCSD is not alone when it comes to abusive administrators. A recent case at UCSD sounds sadly familiar.
In the case below, the woman who brought charges of sexual assault seems to have lost perspective about one instance of touching in between two acts of consensual sex with another student.
UCSD administrators also lost perspective. They threw out most of the evidence in the case.
And then dean Sherry Mallory and the UCSD council of provosts made the situation worse by using abusive measures to deprive a student of due process:
Judge Pressman simultaneously
found that the school's dean Sherry Mallory and the council of provosts
increased the period that John Doe would be suspended from school each
time he tried to appeal the board's decision.
Why do college and K-12 administrators rather frequently act in an arbitrary and abusive manner?
Because they can.
They have lawyers who will help them get away with improper actions--most of the time. Very frequently the Superior Court will rubber stamp just about any action by school officials, but in the following case, the Superior Court didn't tolerate UCSD's abusive behavior in a Title IX hearing.
In my experience, public entity lawyers FREQUENTLY FAIL to advise public officials that they must follow the law. Perhaps the lawyers fear the officials will find other lawyers who will help the officials achieve their goals, whether those goals are lawful or not, rather than instructing them to follow the law.
Administrators at the
University of California San Diego failed to properly investigate sexual
assault allegations against a male student and increased sanctions
against him for appealing their decision, ruled superior court judge
Joel Pressman on Friday, July 10.
A female student accused the
20-year-old male, known as John Doe, of inappropriately touching her on
the morning of February 1, 2014. The male student denied these
allegations and later told an officer who was investigating the
accusations that the two had had sex both the night before and after the
alleged touching occurred. However, John Doe's statements to
investigating officers, as well as other evidence, was not allowed to be
presented during the Title IX sexual misconduct hearing.
"The Court finds that
substantial evidence does not support the finding of non-consensual
sexual activity," reads judge Pressman's July 10 ruling. "First, as
stated above, crucial findings...were based upon [the officer's]
investigation summary that was not presented at the hearing in any
meaningful way. Given the fundamental unfairness of relying on this
report without a meaningful opportunity for petitioner to challenge its
contents, the court has no choice but to exclude the report from
consideration in evaluating whether substantial evidence exists to
support the conclusion."
Furthermore, ruled Pressman,
"The only evidence presented in any meaningful way at the hearing was
the testimony of [the woman]…. Additionally, Ms. Roe admitted that she
voluntarily continued consensual sexual activity with Mr. Doe later that
very same day. The court is not weighing Ms. Roe's credibility. But the
incident on the morning of February 1, cannot be viewed in a vacuum.
When viewed as part of the entire narrative, the sequence of events do [sic]
not demonstrate non-consensual behavior. What the evidence does show is
Ms. Roe's personal regret for engaging in sexual activity beyond her
boundaries."
Judge Pressman simultaneously
found that the school's dean Sherry Mallory and the council of provosts
increased the period that John Doe would be suspended from school each
time he tried to appeal the board's decision.
Initially, the Title IX panel
ordered that John Doe serve a semester suspension, avoid any contact
with the woman, sexual harassment classes, and counseling. Doe, however,
appealed their ruling to Mallory. In response, Mallory increased his
suspension from a semester to an entire year, forcing the student to
reapply to the school. The student then appealed to the council of
provosts. They denied his appeal and added an additional semester to
his year-long suspension.
"Given the lack of rationale by
both Dean Mallory and the Council of Provosts for the increased
sanctions, it appears the increased sanctions are punitive towards
Petitioner for appealing the decision of the Panel," ruled Pressman.
The handling of sexual assault
investigations has come under increased scrutiny at colleges across the
country. Title IX grants colleges the authority to investigate and
conduct hearings on alleged assaults. The hearings are not criminal
hearings, but school administrators do have the authority to expel
students.
Attorneys for the UCSD student celebrated Pressman's decision as a step in the right direction.
“It’s encouraging to see
courts recognizing that sexual misconduct complaints on campus cannot be
resolved at the expense of Constitutional rights and fundamental
fairness,” said Mark Hathaway, an attorney for John Doe in a statement.
“Colleges and universities
must treat all students fairly, regardless of gender. All too often the
male student is just presumed responsible and given no access to any
campus resources. Hopefully Judge Pressman’s ruling will help correct
the imbalance.”
A teacher in Del Mar Union High School District has resigned for unknown reasons. The troublesome issue here is that we can make a pretty safe bet that neither this teacher, nor any of the other teachers at her school, has been effectively observed and evaluated. In most districts, teacher evaluations are a joke. Many principals don't bother to do observations of classrooms. Schools in California and across the country are desperately in need of an effective teacher evaluation system. Did Del Mar get rid of a brilliant
teacher who got in someone's way, or an ineffective, misbehaving
teacher? The author of the article below shows no concern about the well-known
inadequacy of teacher evaluations--and the shameful politics that
controls many, if not most, school district personnel decisions. Obviously, both sides in this case have chosen to keep the facts secret, apparently because both sides have something to hide.
The
Del Mar Union School District and permanent certificated employee,
known as #199-415, have agreed to settle their differences.
This
is according to an “Employment Separation, Settlement Agreement and
Release of All Claims” document which was approved by the DMUSD Board of
Trustees on May 11 at a special closed session board meeting.
The
employee, identified only as a female teacher, went on paid
administrative leave at an unspecified date before May 11. The district
has paid her full regular salary and benefits, less taxes and other
regular withholdings, through June 30, 2015.
The district also
agreed to pay the teacher, who is no longer employed by the district,
the amount of $57,994.46 which is equivalent to “her compensation and
fringe benefits otherwise afforded were her employment to continue
through January 2016.”...
In the agreement, the district “contends
that causes exist to discipline #199-415” but agreed to “cease its
investigation(s) related to allegations of any misconduct” and not
recommend dismissal, suspension or any other type of disciplinary action
against the employee.
Employee #199-415 “denies the district’s
allegations” and “does not admit that she committed acts or omissions
constituting misconduct.”
The agreement states that she
voluntarily chose to resign her permanent certificated employment and to
waive her tenure rights and the right to future employment with the
district...
Both parties release
the other from all claims, grievances and actions, “whether actual or
potential, known or unknown” – and agreed that nothing in the agreement
“shall be construed for any purpose as an admission of fault, error,
wrongdoing or liability.”...
Del
Mar’s trustees met several times in closed session prior to May 11 to
discuss this matter, which was referenced in board meeting agendas as
“Public Employee Evaluation/Dismissal/Discipline/Release.”
Both
parties agreed to keep the settlement confidential and not disclose or
publish the terms of the agreement “to any third party except as may be
required by court order, lawful subpoena or law (i.e., Brown Act,
California Public Records Act or Freedom of Information Act).”...
Who it is doesn’t really matter. What matters is that
taxpayers know that significant general fund money has been spent on
this settlement. And since the public is not privy to details, we can
only hope the district’s elected officials are making wise decisions and
are being good stewards of public funds.
Maura Larkins' comment to Dennis--and to Richard Barrera, who "will ask the board to consider which issues are truly relevant to the school district":