Showing posts with label Bad cops. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bad cops. Show all posts

Friday, December 10, 2010

Five federal judges say California may be about to execute an innocent man

Framed for Murder?
By NICHOLAS D. KRISTOF
New York Times
December 8, 2010

“California may be about to execute an innocent man.”

That’s the view of five federal judges in a case involving Kevin Cooper, a black man in California who faces lethal injection next year for supposedly murdering a white family. The judges argue compellingly that he was framed by police.

Mr. Cooper’s impending execution is so outrageous that it has produced a mutiny among these federal circuit court judges, distinguished jurists just one notch below the United States Supreme Court. But the judicial process has run out for Mr. Cooper. Now it’s up to Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger to decide whether to commute Mr. Cooper’s sentence before leaving office.

This case, an illuminating window into the pitfalls of capital punishment, dates to a horrific quadruple-murder in June 1983. Doug and Peggy Ryen were stabbed to death in their house, along with their 10-year-old daughter and an 11-year-old houseguest. The Ryens’ 8-year-old son, Josh, was left for dead but survived. They were all white.

Josh initially told investigators that the crime had been committed by three people, all white, although by the trial he suggested that he had seen just one person with an Afro. The first version made sense because the weapons included a hatchet, an ice pick and one or two knives. Could one intruder juggling several weapons overpower five victims, including a 200-pound former Marine like Doug Ryen, who also had a loaded rifle nearby?

But the police learned that Mr. Cooper had walked away from the minimum security prison where he was serving a burglary sentence and had hidden in an empty home 125 yards away from the crime scene. The police decided that he had committed the crime alone.

William A. Fletcher, a federal circuit judge, explained his view of what happens in such cases in a law school lecture at Gonzaga University, in which he added that Mr. Cooper is “probably” innocent: “The police are under heavy pressure to solve a high-profile crime. They know, or think they know, who did the crime. And they plant evidence to help their case along.”

Judge Fletcher wrote an extraordinary judicial opinion — more than 100 pages when it was released — dissenting from the refusal of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit to rehear the case. The opinion is a 21st-century version of Émile Zola’s famous “J’Accuse.”

Mr. Fletcher, a well-respected judge and former law professor, was joined in his “J’Accuse” by four other circuit judges. Six more wrote their own dissents calling for the full Ninth Circuit to rehear the case. But they fell just short of the votes needed for rehearing.

Judge Fletcher laid out countless anomalies in the case. Mr. Cooper’s blood showed up on a beige T-shirt apparently left by a murderer near the scene, but that blood turned out to have a preservative in it — the kind of preservative used by police when they keep blood in test tubes.

Then a forensic scientist found that a sample from the test tube of Mr. Cooper’s blood held by police actually contained blood from more than one person. That leads Mr. Cooper’s defense team and Judge Fletcher to believe that someone removed blood and then filled the tube back to the top with someone else’s blood.

The police also ignored other suspects. A woman and her sister told police that a housemate, a convicted murderer who had completed his sentence, had shown up with several other people late on the night of the murders, wearing blood-spattered overalls and driving a station wagon similar to the one stolen from the murdered family.

They said that the man was no longer wearing the beige T-shirt he had on earlier in the evening — the same kind as the one found near the scene. And his hatchet, which resembled the one found near the bodies, was missing from his tool area. The account was supported by a prison confession and by witnesses who said they saw a similar group in blood-spattered clothes in a nearby bar that night. The women gave the bloody overalls to the police for testing, but the police, by now focused on Mr. Cooper, threw the overalls in the trash.

This case is a travesty...

Sunday, May 09, 2010

Judge Rules Post on Cop-Rating Site is Protected Speech

Judge Rules Post on Cop-Rating Site is Protected Speech
By David Kravets
Wired
May 5, 2010

A federal judge has struck down a Florida law prohibiting the publication of a police officer’s name, phone number or address, calling the statute an unconstitutional restraint on speech.

The decision leaves Arizona, Colorado and Washington state with similar laws on the books. Florida authorities said Wednesday they were mulling whether to appeal.

...Robert Brayshaw, a 35-year-old apartment manager, brought the challenge to Florida’s law after he was briefly jail in 2008 for posting personally identifying information of a Tallahassee police officer on RateMyCop.com — a 2-year-old website that lets users rate and comment on the uniformed police officers in their community.

RateMyCop uses public records requests to gather the names and, in some cases, badge numbers of thousands of uniformed cops at police departments around the country, and allows users to post comments about police they’ve interacted with. The site’s launch in 2008 drew cries of outrage from police, who complained that they’d be put at risk if their names were on the internet.

Brayshaw used the site to post anonymous comments about Tallahassee Police Officer Annette Garrett, as well as her name and home address — information not normally cataloged by the site. He wrote that Garrett was rude to him when investigating a trespass call at an apartment complex he was managing.

“He had been investigated for a possible trespass charge, which he was never arrested for,” Brayshaw’s attorney, Anne Swerlick, said in a telephone interview. “He was unsatisfied by the way he was treated.”

The authorities subpoenaed RateMyCop and Brayshaw’s internet service provider to learn his identity, then booked him under the Florida law — a misdemeanor carrying up to a year in jail. The case was later dismissed against Brayshaw for procedural reasons, but he sued, claiming the statute chills his speech.

U.S. District Judge Richard Smoak in Tallahassee agreed, and awarded Brayshaw $25,000 in damages plus legal fees Friday.

The judge ruled the First Amendment does not protect “true threats, fighting words, incitements to imminent lawless action, and classes of lewd and obscene speech.” But publishing an officer’s phone number and address, he said, “is not in itself a threat or serious expression of an intent to commit an unlawful act of violence” (.pdf).

Smoak wrote that he appreciated the intent of the 38-year-old law, but noted that it went too far. “While the state interest of protecting police officers from harm or death may be compelling,” the judge said the law “was not narrowly tailored to serve this interest.”

Read More http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/05/first-amendment-cops/#ixzz0nSY21lt9

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Woman wrongly arrested wants apology from police, Bonnie Dumanis

Stories like this make me realize why there are so many innocent people who are released when their DNA is tested: eyewitness identification is pretty close to worthless, especially across racial lines. If there hadn't been a video for a clear-eyed judge to look at, this woman might still have charges pending against her. Couldn't District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis find a black cop to take a look at the video? The problem might have been solved a lot sooner if she had.


I don't understand why some people can't apologize when they make a harmful mistake. It makes me wonder if the police and District Attorney think that it's okay for them to trample on people like this and then shrug it off. This isn't what we pay them to do. They get high salaries to do a thorough, professional job.

Woman wrongly arrested wants apology
By Brian Flores
FOX 5 San Diego
April 14, 2010

LA MESA, Calif. - A La Mesa woman who was mistakenly arrested for a series of crimes against senior citizens says she wants and apology from the San Diego District Attorney's Office and police.

Deidria Nicholson told Fox 5 News that she didn't know what she was being arrested for Thursday, but she knew it was a serious situation.

"I can tell you that at that moment, I did not fully understand the charges against me," Nicholson said. "But when I got outside and saw the media, I thought, somebody out here made a big mistake."

Earlier this month, police released a video surveillance photo of a woman responsible for a string of burglaries against local elderly people. Investigators received a phone tip last Thursday that led them to Nicholson. Nicholson said her La Mesa apartment was surrounded by 10 to 14 police officers that afternoon. She said the officers gathered evidence, including receipts, post cards, and some of her hair products. She said she was taken away in handcuffs.

Nicholson's son, Ellis Twine II, said his mother's arrest was bewildering to everyone who knows her.

"I was just shocked, and everybody I told about was in shock, thinking if it was an April fool's joke or something," Twine said.

Nicholson spent five days in custody. She was arraigned Monday afternoon and pleaded not guilty. She adamantly maintained that she was a victim of mistaken identity. Just hours after the arraignment, prosecutors dropped all charges and Nicholson was released. Authorities said they had arrested the wrong person...

Thursday, February 25, 2010

Ex-Officer Pleads Guilty in Katrina Killing Probe

Times Picayune photo

Lance Madison is arrested by State Police and NOPD SWAT members on Sept. 4, 2005, after a confrontation with police near the Danziger Bridge in eastern New Orleans. Ronald Madison, Lance Madison's brother, was shot to death that day.


Ex-Officer Pleads Guilty in Katrina Killing Probe
Mary Foster and Mike Jenzelman
AP
Feb. 25, 2010
In Hurricane Katrina's chaotic aftermath, police shot six people -- killing two -- as they crossed a bridge in search of food. For years the case was a shocking symbol of the confusion and violence that swept through the flooded city. On Wednesday it became a mark of shame for the police department.

As victims' relatives watched from the courtroom gallery, a retired lieutenant who supervised the department's probe of the shootings pleaded guilty to orchestrating a cover-up to conceal that police gunned down unarmed civilians.

Michael Lohman, a 21-year veteran of the force, pleaded guilty to a charge of conspiracy to obstruct justice. Prosecutors said Lohman and other unidentified officers conspired to fabricate witness statements, falsify reports of the incident and plant a gun in an attempt to make it appear the killings were justified.

U.S. Attorney Jim Letten said the investigation is continuing and would not say whether higher-ranking officials of the police department might be involved.

Lohman's plea brought at least some closure to families of victims in the best-known of several violent incidents that raised questions about police conduct immediately after Katrina. The shootings happened on Sept. 4, 2005, six days after the storm smashed levees and flooded 80 percent of the city.

Survivors have said the officers fired at unarmed people who were crossing to get food at a grocery store. The officers claimed they opened fire only after being shot at. Ronald Madison, 40 and mentally disabled, and James Brissette, 19, were killed and four others were wounded.

"We are very, very happy about the progress that the FBI and the U.S. Justice Department have made," said Romell Madison, Ronald's brother. "The people of New Orleans should be relieved that there is still justice for everybody here."

Lohman's plea marked the first conviction in the case. Seven officers were charged with murder or attempted murder but a state judge threw out all the charges. Federal authorities then stepped in to investigate...

"It looks like the blue code has been broken," former U.S. Attorney Harry Rosenberg said. "Remember, those officers stood shoulder to shoulder when it was in state court. Nobody said anything."

The "blue code" is likely to face further tests with Lohman's cooperation as federal prosecutors probe the fatal shooting by police of Danny Brumfield Sr. outside the New Orleans convention center; the death of Henry Glover, whom witnesses claim died in police custody; and the fatal police shooting of a Connecticut man, Matthew McDonald...

Friday, October 19, 2007

Bonnie Dumanis thinks we should not tolerate bullies--unless they work for her


Bonnie Dumanis, speaking with a forked tongue, says, "Public officials should never be permitted to govern by fear and we should never tolerate bullies terrorizing our citizens."

Unless, of course, the bullies are the District Attorney and sheriff's deputies, right, Bonnie?

In that case, a little fear and terror goes a long way. Say, for example, if a sheriff's deputy kills his wife in front of his own young son. Or if his buddies assault the parent of the dying woman. In cases like this, a girl has to protect her own if she wants to hold on to her office, right, Bonnie?

But if a Democrat takes two hours off work to try to get a picture of Cheryl Cox and David Malcolm, well, a girl's got to take a stand. File five felonies against him!

Which makes me wonder: was it just William Gentry working alone who came up with the shameful Bruce plea deal, which was rejected by Judge Exarhos, or did Gentry get guidance from Bonnie Dumanis?

Shame on Bonnie Dumanis for supporting the friend of a wife-killer

Bonnie Dumanis has sunk to a new low. She is supporting William Gentry, Jr. for city attorney.

The two of them have a bad habit of covering up wrongdoing.

Gentry came up with a plea deal for Lowell “Sam” Bryan Bruce, a sheriff's deputy who killed his wife in front of their young son, that raised questions about whether Bruce was getting special treatment because of his job in law enforcement.

"The judge said prosecutors should either try Bruce on murder charges as planned or refile the case on lesser charges if they think Bruce should get a lower sentence," according to a SDUT article on July 13, 2007.

Apparently Bruce's buddies in the sheriff's department were also anxious to take his side in the wife-killing.

The victim's father said sheriff's deputies doused him with pepper spray, hit him with a baton and kept him from getting to his daughter as she lay dying on a stretcher in the driveway of their home.

The 38-year-old wife was shot once in the jaw, and died an hour later waiting for medical care. Why didn't they just drive her to the hospital?

Taxpayers would be better off if public employees were held accountable, not let off the hook by craven prosecutors like Gentry. The family of Bruce's wife has a good case against the county. Our current policies regarding crimes by sheriff's deputies will cost us plenty. County employees like this killer and his friends, including William Gentry, should be fired.

"Prosecutor" William Gentry, Jr. couldn't get his shameful plea deal past a judge

This guy wants to be city attorney?

William Gentry Jr. is so soft on crime that the plea deal he arranged for a sheriff's deputy who fatally shot his wife in front of their young son was rejected by a judge who said, "I do not feel this is in the best interest of the administration of justice."

San Diego Superior Court Judge Herbert J. Exarhos said the disparity was too great between the prison term Bruce would get under the agreement and the 40-years-to-life maximum penalty he faces if he's tried and convicted, according to a July 13, 2007 article by Ray Huard in the San Diego Union Tribune.

UPDATE:
NOV. 9, 2007
LOWELL BRUCE STILL HASN’T BEEN SENTENCED. HIS ATTORNEYS HAVE FILED A MOTION SAYING THAT THE SECOND JUDGE IN THIS CASE, ALLAN J. PRECKEL, IS JUST AS PREJUDICED AGAINST HIM AS THE FIRST JUDGE. THEY ARE ASKING FOR A THIRD JUDGE TO BE CHOSEN IN THE CASE.

They appear to be looking for a judge who thinks cops who murder their wives deserve better treatment than others who murder their wives. They want a judge who thinks like William Gentry, Jr., the prosecutor who is running for city attorney of San Diego. He reduced the charge from murder to voluntary manslaughter. How can we have the rule of law when those who are supposed to enforce it don't follow the laws themselves, Mr. Gentry?